Partial Ionic Character of Covalent Bonds — Question 2

Section 8-6 · Chemistry pages 1389–1390

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Compare equal dipoles at unequal bond lengths

Two neutral diatomic models have the same nonzero dipole magnitude. Their bond lengths are 120 pm and 180 pm. Each uses μ=qeffr\mu=q_{\mathrm{eff}}r and the same elementary-charge reference.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the effective-charge ratio for the shorter bond relative to the longer bond.

  2. Which has the greater dipole-based ionic percentage, and why can dipole alone mislead?

Question 2 - Solution

Compare equal dipoles at unequal bond lengths

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

q120/q180=(μ/120)/(μ/180)=180/120=1.50q_{120}/q_{180}=(\mu/120)/(\mu/180)=180/120=1.50.

(b) Analysis

The shorter bond has the greater fitted charge and ionic percentage, by a factor of 1.50. A longer lever arm produces the same dipole with less charge separation, so equal dipoles do not imply equal ionic fractions.

Check and interpretation

The conclusion holds within the same two-point-charge convention.