Partial Ionic Character of Covalent Bonds — Question 8

Section 8-6 · Chemistry pages 1401–1402

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Use a controlled polarization model

In a simplified ion-pair model, the induced distortion measure is proportional to αz/r2\alpha z/r^2, where α\alpha is anion polarizability, z is cation charge magnitude, and r is separation. Compare P with (α,z,r)=(1,1,200)(\alpha,z,r)=(1,1,200) and Q with (2,2,200)(2,2,200) in common units.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the distortion ratio Q/P.

  2. Explain qualitatively why strong distortion can make the rigid full-charge ionic picture less adequate.

Question 8 - Solution

Use a controlled polarization model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The ratio is [2(2)/2002]/[1(1)/2002]=4[2(2)/200^2]/[1(1)/200^2]=4. Both increased polarizability and increased field strength contribute.

(b) Analysis

An anion cloud deformed toward a neighboring cation is no longer well represented by an unchanged spherical ion carrying a point charge. Shared/interpenetrating density can become more important. The model predicts distortion, not an exact universal covalent percentage.

Check and interpretation

The comparison controls separation and uses only the stated proportional model.