Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Cancel unchanged bonds in hydrogenation
For in the gas phase, use C=C = 614, H–H = 436, C–C = 347 and C–H = 413 kJ/mol.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the estimated reaction enthalpy using only the net changed bonds.
Show why counting all four original C–H bonds as net broken would be an error.
Question 2 - Solution
Cancel unchanged bonds in hydrogenation
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Net changes break one C=C and one H–H and form one C–C plus two C–H. Thus kJ/mol reaction.
(b) Analysis
Four C–H bonds exist on both sides and cancel in the average-bond model. A full atomization route may break all reactant bonds, but must then form all six product C–H bonds; retaining only one side of those unchanged contributions is inconsistent.
Check and interpretation
Cancellation is bookkeeping in an average-energy model, not a proposed stepwise mechanism.