The Molecular Orbital Model — Question 7

Section 9-2 · Chemistry pages 1579–1580

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Use symmetry to decide whether overlap cancels

The internuclear axis is z. A 1s orbital on A interacts with either pzp_z or pxp_x on B. For the s–pxp_x pair, reflection x→−xx\to-x leaves the s function unchanged and reverses the p function.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why the s–pxp_x overlap integral vanishes in the ideal geometry.

  2. Which p orientation can form a sigma interaction with s, and what other condition affects mixing strength?

Question 7 - Solution

Use symmetry to decide whether overlap cancels

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Every positive contribution to the integral has an equal negative reflected partner. Their sum is zero, so the transverse s–pxp_x overlap cancels.

(b) Analysis

The axial pzp_z orbital has suitable sigma symmetry. Matching symmetry permits interaction, but spatial overlap and the energy separation also control its magnitude.

Check and interpretation

Symmetry permission does not guarantee strong mixing.