Combining the Localized Electron and Molecular Orbital Models — Question 3

Section 9-5 · Chemistry pages 1631–1632

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Fill a three-center conjugated fragment

A planar allyl fragment has three aligned p orbitals and three pi MOs: bonding, nonbonding and antibonding in ascending energy. The cation has two pi electrons, the radical three and the anion four.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Give occupations and the number of unpaired electrons for each.

  2. Under the stipulated index (Nbonding−Nantibonding)/2(N_{\mathrm{bonding}}-N_{\mathrm{antibonding}})/2, find the total pi bonding index of each. Explain its limitation.

Question 3 - Solution

Fill a three-center conjugated fragment

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The cation has two electrons in the bonding MO and none elsewhere: zero unpaired. The radical adds one to the nonbonding MO: one unpaired. The anion pairs that nonbonding electron: zero unpaired.

(b) Analysis

Each has two bonding and zero antibonding pi electrons, so the stated index is 1. Occupying the nonbonding level changes charge and spin without changing this index; it does not prove identical bond energies or charge distributions.

Check and interpretation

This multi-center index is defined for the exercise and is not a unique pairwise bond-order measurement.