Combining the Localized Electron and Molecular Orbital Models — Question 4

Section 9-5 · Chemistry pages 1633–1634

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Show why orbital localization need not change density

Two orthonormal real occupied orbitals ψ1\psi_1 and ψ2\psi_2 each contain two electrons. Define χA=(ψ1+ψ2)/2\chi_A=(\psi_1+\psi_2)/\sqrt2 and χB=(ψ1−ψ2)/2\chi_B=(\psi_1-\psi_2)/\sqrt2. At one point, ψ1=0.30\psi_1=0.30 and ψ2=0.40\psi_2=0.40 in common amplitude units.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate 2ψ12+2ψ222\psi_1^2+2\psi_2^2 and 2χA2+2χB22\chi_A^2+2\chi_B^2 at that point.

  2. Show algebraically why the equality holds everywhere and explain its relation to localized versus delocalized occupied orbitals.

Question 4 - Solution

Show why orbital localization need not change density

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The original density is 2(0.09+0.16)=0.502(0.09+0.16)=0.50. The transformed values are 0.70/20.70/\sqrt2 and −0.10/2-0.10/\sqrt2, so the density is 2(0.49/2+0.01/2)=0.502(0.49/2+0.01/2)=0.50.

(b) Analysis

Adding the two squared transformed functions cancels the cross terms: χA2+χB2=ψ12+ψ22\chi_A^2+\chi_B^2=\psi_1^2+\psi_2^2. Rotating among equally occupied orbitals can change their appearance while preserving total density. Individual localized orbitals need not remain energy eigenfunctions.

Check and interpretation

The equal occupations are essential to this simple density identity; arbitrary mixing with empty orbitals is not equivalent.