Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Use orbital phases to distinguish chain modes
For four adjacent p orbitals, two trial sign patterns for the upper lobes are A: + + + + and B: + + - -. All coefficients are nonzero. Count only sign-change nodes between neighboring centers, and use the qualitative rule that extra such nodes usually raise pi-orbital energy in a comparable chain.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Count these nodes for A and B and identify which is expected lower.
If every sign in B is reversed, do its density, node count and energy change?
Question 9 - Solution
Use orbital phases to distinguish chain modes
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
A has no sign change between neighbors. B has one, between centers 2 and 3. A is therefore expected lower in the stated comparison.
(b) Analysis
Reversing all coefficients changes the overall sign of the orbital, leaving its squared density and nodal pattern unchanged. Its energy is unchanged. Changing only selected signs, by contrast, can alter interference and nodes.
Check and interpretation
The usual nodal plane containing the nuclei is shared by pi orbitals; this question counts additional nodes between centers.