Area with Parametric Equations — Question 5

PDF ↗

Question 5

Problem

A simple, piecewise smooth closed curve is traversed once clockwise. Explain why ∫ydx\int y\,dx may be positive even though area cannot be negative.

See the diagram in the original worksheet below.

Original worksheet page 1: question and worked solution for 3-3-005
Show solutionHide solution

Question 5 – Solution

See the diagram in the original worksheet below.

Solution

  1. A line integral around a closed curve is signed: reversing the direction of traversal reverses the sign because dxdx changes sign.

  2. For a positively oriented, counterclockwise curve CC, Green’s theorem gives A=−∮Cydx.A=-\oint_C y\,dx. Thus ∮Cydx=−A\oint_C y\,dx=-A for counterclockwise traversal.

  3. If the same boundary is traversed clockwise, the line integral changes sign: ∮−Cydx=−∮Cydx=A.\oint_{-C}y\,dx=-\oint_Cy\,dx=A. Therefore, ∫ydx\int y\,dx can be positive for clockwise motion; the sign describes orientation, not a negative or positive physical area by itself.

  4. A direction-independent formula for geometric area is A=|∮Cydx|.\boxed{A=\left|\oint_C y\,dx\right|}. Equivalently, use −∮Cydx-\oint_Cy\,dx with counterclockwise orientation or reverse the bounds when necessary.

Original worksheet page 2: question and worked solution for 3-3-005

Original worksheet layout. Use Enlarge or open the PDF for a closer view.