Divergence Theorem — Question 9

Section 19-6 · Calculus pages 3597–3598

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

On ℝ3\{𝟎}\mathbb R^3\setminus\{\mathbf 0\}, consider 𝑭(x,y,z)=⟨x,y,z⟩(x2+y2+z2)3/2.\mathbf F(x,y,z)=\frac{\langle x,y,z\rangle}{(x^2+y^2+z^2)^{3/2}}. Let SS be the outward-oriented unit sphere.

Tasks

  1. Compute the flux through SS directly.

  2. Explain why zero divergence away from the origin does not permit applying the Divergence Theorem to the full unit ball.

  3. Reconcile the result using a punctured ball.

Question 9 – Solution

Strategy. The nonzero flux is caused by a singularity inside the sphere; remove a small ball so the theorem’s hypotheses hold.

Step 1: Direct flux On the unit sphere, 𝑭=𝒏\mathbf F=\mathbf n, so ∬S𝑭⋅𝒏dS=∬S1dS=4π.\boxed{\iint_S\mathbf F\cdot\mathbf n\,dS =\iint_S1\,dS=4\pi}. Although ∇⋅𝑭=0\nabla\cdot\mathbf F=0 for r>0r>0, the field is undefined at the origin and is not smooth throughout the full ball.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

Step 2: Puncture the ball Remove the ball r<εr<\varepsilon. On the shell ε≤r≤1\varepsilon\le r\le 1, the divergence is zero, so the total outward flux is zero.

Step 3: Track both boundaries The outer flux is 4π4\pi. On r=εr=\varepsilon, the shell’s outward normal is −𝒆r-\mathbf e_r, while 𝑭=𝒆r/ε2\mathbf F=\mathbf e_r/\varepsilon^2. Thus Φr=ε=−1ε2(4πε2)=−4π.\Phi_{r=\varepsilon}=-\frac 1{\varepsilon^2}(4\pi\varepsilon^2)=-4\pi. Therefore 4π−4π=04\pi-4\pi=0, consistent with the theorem on the punctured region.

Verification The inner flux remains −4π-4\pi as ε→0+\varepsilon\to 0^+, recording the enclosed point source rather than disappearing.