Final Thoughts — Question 1

PDF ↗

Question 1

Consider the initial value problem y′=e−x2,y(0)=1.y'=e^{-x^2},\qquad y(0)=1. A proposed answer is F(x)=1+∫0xe−t2dt.F(x)=1+\int_0^x e^{-t^2}\,dt. A student rejects this expression because the integral has no elementary antiderivative. You may take that non-elementarity as given; proving it is not part of this problem.

Tasks

  1. Verify FF as an exact solution and state its interval of definition.

  2. Prove uniqueness directly: if GG is another solution with G(0)=1G(0)=1 on an interval containing 00, show that G=FG=F there.

  3. Without evaluating the integral numerically, prove the bounds 1+e−1<F(1)<2.1+e^{-1}<F(1)<2.

  4. Explain the distinction between an exact representation, an elementary formula, and a numerical approximation. Does the lack of an elementary antiderivative imply that the IVP has no solution?

Original worksheet page 1: question and worked solution for 1-3-001
Show solutionHide solution

Question 1 – Solution

Strategy. A definite integral defines a function. The Fundamental Theorem of Calculus can verify that function even when elementary antidifferentiation is unavailable.

Step 1: Verification and domain. The integrand is continuous for every real tt, so the integral exists for every finite real xx. The Fundamental Theorem gives F′(x)=e−x2,F(0)=1+0=1.F'(x)=e^{-x^2},\qquad F(0)=1+0=1. Thus F is an exact solution on ℝ.\boxed{F\text{ is an exact solution on }\mathbb R.} Negative xx causes no problem: the integral is interpreted with reversed limits.

Step 2: Uniqueness without a general theorem. If GG solves the same IVP on an interval II containing 00, then (G−F)′=e−x2−e−x2=0.(G-F)'=e^{-x^2}-e^{-x^2}=0. A differentiable function with zero derivative on an interval is constant there. At 00, G−F=0G-F=0, so G(x)=F(x)(x∈I).\boxed{G(x)=F(x)\quad(x\in I).}

Step 3: Strict integral bounds. For 0<t<10<t<1, e−1<e−t2<1.e^{-1}<e^{-t^2}<1. These strict inequalities hold throughout an interval of positive length. Integrating from 00 to 11 therefore gives e−1<∫01e−t2dt<1,1+e−1<F(1)<2.e^{-1}<\int_0^1 e^{-t^2}\,dt<1, \qquad \boxed{1+e^{-1}<F(1)<2.}

Step 4: What counts as a solution. The definite-integral expression specifies FF exactly, with no rounding. An elementary formula is a more restricted type of expression, assembled from familiar elementary functions. A decimal obtained by numerical integration is an approximation to a value of FF. Failure to find an elementary expression does not negate the exact solution already verified.

Original worksheet page 2: question and worked solution for 1-3-001

Original worksheet layout. Use Enlarge or open the PDF for a closer view.