Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Does organic mean biological?
Consider methane collected from a biological process and methane synthesized from nonbiological starting materials. Both are pure .
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Are both organic under the usual convention?
State a molecular criterion for comparing them.
Explain why the label “organic” is not by itself a statement about safety or environmental impact.
Question 5 - Solution
Does organic mean biological?
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| Methane |
Connectivity drawing of methane; the planar page does not imply a planar molecule.
(a)
Yes. Methane is an organic compound regardless of its source. A living origin is not required.
(b)
Compare atom identities, isotope composition where relevant, connectivity, and electronic state. Identical methane molecules have the same chemical identity; source alone does not introduce a new kind of C–H bond.
(c)
A subject-area label contains no dose, exposure, concentration, persistence, or conditions. Those are separate questions. Neither an organic classification nor a biological origin proves that a material is harmless or environmentally preferable.