VSEPR Theory - Predicting Geometry — Question 10

Section 1-10 · Organic Chemistry pages 209–210

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Deriving the tetrahedral angle from symmetry

Four ideal bond directions are proportional to (1,1,1)(1,1,1), (1,−1,−1)(1,-1,-1), (−1,1,−1)(-1,1,-1), and (−1,−1,1)(-1,-1,1). Use cos⁡θ=𝒂⋅𝒃/(|𝒂||𝒃|)\cos\theta=\mathbf a\cdot\mathbf b/(|\mathbf a||\mathbf b|).

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Tetrahedral methane
  1. Calculate the angle between the first two directions.

  2. Show why every pair gives the same angle.

  3. Explain why a square-planar drawing with four 90∘90^\circ neighbors is not the ordinary VSEPR prediction for methane.

Question 10 - Solution

Deriving the tetrahedral angle from symmetry

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Tetrahedral methane

Wedges communicate depth; the projected paper angles are not the true interbond angles.

(a)

The dot product is 1−1−1=−11-1-1=-1; both lengths are 3\sqrt3. Thus cos⁡θ=−1/3\cos\theta=-1/3, giving θ≈109.47∘\theta\approx109.47^\circ.

(b)

Any two different listed vectors agree in one coordinate and differ in two. Every dot product is therefore −1-1, so all six interbond angles are equal.

(c)

Four equivalent bonding domains with no lone pairs occupy tetrahedral directions in the basic VSEPR model. A flat cross is a connectivity convention, not evidence of square-planar carbon. Square-planar molecules elsewhere require different electronic/domain contexts.