Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Same bonds, different cancellation
Treat both 1,2-dichloroethene structures as planar. Consider equal C–Cl bond-dipole magnitudes and the symmetry of each complete structure.
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| cis |
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| trans |
Predict which isomer has zero permanent dipole by symmetry.
Explain why the other can have a nonzero resultant.
Explain why identical formulas and counts of polar bonds do not determine molecular polarity.
Question 5 - Solution
Same bonds, different cancellation
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| cis |
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| trans |
Both alkene carbons are trigonal planar; the chlorine positions control the symmetry.
(a)
The trans isomer has inversion symmetry: every bond-polarity contribution has an equal opposite partner. Its permanent dipole is zero.
(b)
In the cis isomer, the C–Cl contributions have components pointing toward the same side of the C=C axis. Those components add rather than cancel; a nonzero molecular dipole is allowed and expected.
(c)
Formula and bond counts omit the relative orientations of the bond dipoles. Cis and trans arrangements preserve those counts while changing vector cancellation. Geometry must accompany local polarity information.