Intermolecular Forces and Physical Properties — Question 8

Section 1-12 · Organic Chemistry pages 245–246

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Why a boiling-point rule may fail for melting

Two hypothetical isomers have similar liquid-phase cohesive interactions, but isomer A packs more efficiently in its crystal than B.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

The two phase changes compare different pairs of states.

  1. Explain why their melting points could differ substantially.

  2. Does this information fix their boiling-point order?

  3. Explain why a measured melting point can depend on which crystal form is present.

Question 8 - Solution

Why a boiling-point rule may fail for melting

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Melting compares the free energies of solid and liquid. More favorable crystal packing can stabilize the solid, although the entropy of fusion also matters, so the melting point can change substantially even for similar liquids.

(b)

No. Boiling compares liquid and vapor; the supplied distinction concerns solid packing. It does not by itself establish a liquid-to-vapor free-energy ordering.

(c)

Different crystal forms can have different packing, energies and entropies. Their solid free energies need not cross the liquid free energy at the same temperature. A single intermolecular-force label is therefore insufficient to predict all phase transitions.