Solubility — Question 2

Section 1-13 · Organic Chemistry pages 253–254

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

An acceptor-only solute can still interact with water

A student claims acetone cannot hydrogen-bond with water because acetone has no O–H bond.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Acetone
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Water
  1. Identify a valid donor–acceptor pairing between these molecules.

  2. Explain the flaw in the student’s argument.

  3. Explain why one favorable interaction alone is not a universal proof of complete miscibility for every carbonyl compound.

Question 2 - Solution

An acceptor-only solute can still interact with water

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Acetone
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Water

The carbonyl oxygen is the accepting site; water supplies the donor H.

(a)

A water O–H group donates a hydrogen bond to an acetone oxygen lone pair: Owater−H⋯Ocarbonyl.\mathrm{O_{water}-H\cdots O_{carbonyl}}.

(b)

Acetone need not be the donor. It can accept a hydrogen bond from a solvent that supplies the donor. Solute self-hydrogen-bonding and solute–water hydrogen bonding are different tests.

(c)

The rest of the molecule matters, including the size of its nonpolar region, and mixing replaces pre-existing solvent–solvent and solute–solute contacts. A carbonyl acceptor can favor hydration without guaranteeing that every carbonyl-containing molecule mixes with water in all proportions.