Solubility — Question 10

Section 1-13 · Organic Chemistry pages 269–270

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Selecting a solvent under a practical constraint

For 6.00 g of a hypothetical solid, use the supplied hot and cold solubilities. Assume unchanged volumes, no reaction, equilibrium and perfect collection. At most 75.0 mL solvent is available.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

Hypothetical solvent-screening data; hot and cold temperatures are fixed for each comparison.

  1. Find the minimum hot solvent volume for A and B.

  2. At each minimum volume, calculate ideal cold crystal recovery.

  3. Select the feasible solvent under the volume constraint and explain the recovery/volume tradeoff.

Question 10 - Solution

Selecting a solvent under a practical constraint

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

A requires 100(6.00/12.0)=50.0mL100(6.00/12.0)=50.0\ \mathrm{mL}. B requires 100(6.00/3.00)=200mL100(6.00/3.00)=200\ \mathrm{mL}.

(b)

A retains 1.00(50.0/100)=0.500g1.00(50.0/100)=0.500\ \mathrm g cold, yielding 5.50 g (91.7%). B retains 0.100(200/100)=0.200g0.100(200/100)=0.200\ \mathrm g, yielding 5.80 g (96.7%).

(c)

Only A fits the 75.0 mL limit while dissolving all 6.00 g hot. B has the higher ideal recovery at its minimum volume but requires four times as much solvent. The best choice depends on explicit constraints, not cold solubility alone.