Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Repairing a pentavalent carbon
The proposed drawing is intended to be a neutral, closed-shell hydrocarbon with only single bonds.
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| Proposed neutral drawing |
Deliberately incorrect proposal: inspect the central atom.
Identify the valence error.
Repair it by changing only one hydrogen subscript, keeping all C–C connections.
Give the repaired formula and explain why adding a formal charge is not an appropriate shortcut here.
Question 2 - Solution
Repairing a pentavalent carbon
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| Corrected structure |
The central carbon now has exactly four single bonds.
(a)
The central has three C–C single bonds and two C–H bonds: five bonds at a second-row carbon.
(b)
Change central to . Its four single bonds then give normal carbon valence. The three terminal methyl groups plus one central H give .
(c)
A charge label does not remove the ten electrons implied around a five-bond carbon. The problem specifies an ordinary neutral closed-shell hydrocarbon; correcting the hydrogen count restores that model.