The Structural Theory of Matter — Question 6

Section 1-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 41–42

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Constructing a structure from a neighbor list

There are three carbons and one oxygen. The complete heavy-atom neighbor list is shown; no other heavy-atom bonds exist. Assume neutral atoms with ordinary valences C = 4, O = 2, H = 1.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Add the required H atoms.

  2. Write the molecular formula.

  3. Explain why oxygen cannot also carry an H in this neutral structure.

Question 6 - Solution

Constructing a structure from a neighbor list

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Reconstructed molecule

(a)

C1 has one heavy-atom bond and needs three H. C2 has two heavy-atom bonds and needs two H. C3 has one heavy-atom bond and needs three H. Oxygen already has its two bonds.

(b)

The result is , formula .

(c)

An extra O–H connection would make three bonds at oxygen. An octet oxygen with three single bonds and one lone pair has formal charge +1+1, violating the stipulated neutral ordinary-valence description. Hydrogen cannot be added merely because oxygen often occurs in an OH group.