Electrons, Bonds, and Lewis Structures — Question 3

Section 1-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 55–56

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

A missing-lone-pair error in methanol

The student says the drawing is a complete Lewis structure of neutral methanol. All C–H bonds in are understood.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Student drawing
  1. Count the electrons represented and compare with the formula’s budget.

  2. Repair the drawing.

  3. Explain the difference between a permissible abbreviated structural formula and a claimed complete Lewis structure.

Question 3 - Solution

A missing-lone-pair error in methanol

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Corrected

(a)

Methanol has 4+4+6=144+4+6=14 valence electrons. Five single bonds represent ten electrons, and the one shown lone pair adds two: only twelve are represented.

(b)

Add a second oxygen lone pair. Oxygen then has two bond pairs and two lone pairs, eight electrons around it; the total is fourteen.

(c)

An ordinary structural formula may omit nonbonding electrons when understood by convention. A complete Lewis representation must account for them. The error is not the existence of an abbreviated formula; it is calling an incomplete electron inventory complete.