Electrons, Bonds, and Lewis Structures — Question 6

Section 1-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 61–62

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Two ways to misuse the CO2 electron budget

Two proposals use the shown connectivity. Proposal P gives each terminal O three lone pairs and leaves both bonds single. Proposal Q uses two double bonds but retains three lone pairs on each O.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Skeleton
  1. Audit the electron count and carbon octet in P.

  2. Audit the electron count and O octets in Q.

  3. Supply the correct neutral octet structure.

Question 6 - Solution

Two ways to misuse the CO2 electron budget

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Correct

(a)

has 4+2(6)=164+2(6)=16 valence electrons. P uses four bonding electrons plus twelve nonbonding electrons, so its total is correct, but carbon has only four electrons around it.

(b)

Q uses eight bonding plus twelve nonbonding electrons, twenty in all. Each O has ten electrons around it, also violating a second-row octet.

(c)

Use O=C=O with two lone pairs on each oxygen. Eight bonding plus eight nonbonding electrons gives sixteen; all three atoms have octets. A correct total alone is not enough: local electron counts must also be checked.