Electrons, Bonds, and Lewis Structures — Question 8

Section 1-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 65–66

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Why an odd electron total matters

The species is the neutral methyl radical, .

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Methyl skeleton
  1. Find its valence-electron budget and allocate electrons.

  2. Explain why an all-paired closed-shell Lewis structure is impossible for this isolated species.

  3. Contrast its carbon electron count with methane.

Question 8 - Solution

Why an odd electron total matters

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Methyl radical
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Methane

(a)

Ne=4+3=7N_e=4+3=7. Three C–H bonds use six electrons; the remaining electron is unpaired on carbon.

(b)

An odd number cannot be divided entirely into pairs. Giving carbon a lone pair would require eight electrons and describe , not the neutral radical.

(c)

The radical has seven electrons around carbon: six shared plus one unpaired. Methane has four C–H bonds and eight electrons around carbon. An incomplete octet in the radical is required by the stated electron count, not a drawing oversight.