Identifying Formal Charges — Question 1

Section 1-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 71–72

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

One carbon skeleton, three electronic states

Use FC=V−N−B/2\mathrm{FC}=V-N-B/2, where NN is the number of nonbonding electrons and BB the number of bonding electrons. Each carbon has three C–H bonds; A has no nonbonding electron, B has one, and C has a lone pair.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
C
  1. Calculate the carbon formal charge in A–C.

  2. Give the total electrons around carbon in each.

  3. Identify the closed-shell anion, radical, and electron-deficient cation.

Question 1 - Solution

One carbon skeleton, three electronic states

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
C

The same three C–H bonds coexist with three different nonbonding-electron inventories.

(a)

Each carbon has V=4V=4 and B=6B=6: A gives 4−0−3=+14-0-3=+1, B gives 4−1−3=04-1-3=0, and C gives 4−2−3=−14-2-3=-1.

(b)

Counts around carbon are six, seven, and eight respectively. Shared electrons count fully for an octet test but only half when assigning formal charge.

(c)

A is , an electron-deficient carbocation; B is the neutral methyl radical; C is the closed-shell methyl anion . The number of bonds alone does not determine charge unless nonbonding electrons are also known.