Identifying Formal Charges — Question 4

Section 1-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 77–78

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Locating the charge in cyanide

Use FC=V−N−B/2\mathrm{FC}=V-N-B/2, where NN is the number of nonbonding electrons and BB the number of bonding electrons. The species has total charge −1-1. Both atoms have one lone pair.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Given Lewis structure
  1. Find the formal charge on each atom.

  2. Check the total valence-electron budget for .

  3. Explain why placing the minus sign on N simply because N is more electronegative would not match the drawing.

Question 4 - Solution

Locating the charge in cyanide

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Cyanide

(a)

Carbon: 4−2−3=−14-2-3=-1. Nitrogen: 5−2−3=05-2-3=0.

(b)

4+5+1=104+5+1=10 electrons are available. Six are in the triple bond and four in the two lone pairs. The sum of formal charges is −1-1, as required.

(c)

Once a Lewis structure is fixed, charge follows its bond and lone-pair counts. Electronegativity may help compare alternative contributors, but it cannot override the arithmetic for the specified drawing. Here carbon carries the negative formal charge.