Identifying Formal Charges — Question 7

Section 1-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 83–84

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Charge bookkeeping in a donor–acceptor adduct

In the adduct, N is bonded to three H and B; B is bonded to three H and N. Neither atom has a lone pair. Use N = 5 and B = 3 valence electrons.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Adduct
  1. Assign formal charges.

  2. Compare with separated (one N lone pair) and (no B lone pair).

  3. Explain why the electron-pair donor becomes formally positive.

Question 7 - Solution

Charge bookkeeping in a donor–acceptor adduct

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Adduct charges

(a)

N: 5−0−4=+15-0-4=+1. B: 3−0−4=−13-0-4=-1. The adduct is net neutral.

(b)

Separate ammonia has 5−2−3=05-2-3=0 on N; separate borane has 3−0−3=03-0-3=0 on B. Forming the N–B bond converts the N lone pair into a shared pair.

(c)

Formal-charge accounting assigns both lone-pair electrons to N before bonding but only one of the new bond electrons to N afterward. N therefore loses one assigned electron and becomes formally +1+1. This is bookkeeping, not removal of a whole electron from the molecule.