Identifying Formal Charges — Question 10

Section 1-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 89–90

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Following a bonding pair during heterolysis

Imagine the C–Cl bond breaks and both electrons of that bond are assigned to chlorine. This is a bookkeeping exercise, not a prediction of spontaneous gas-phase cleavage.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Starting molecule
  1. Draw the two fragments with their nonbonding electrons.

  2. Assign each formal charge.

  3. Verify conservation of total charge and total valence electrons.

Question 10 - Solution

Following a bonding pair during heterolysis

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Methyl cation
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Chloride

(a)

The fragments are , with no C lone pair, and , with four lone pairs.

(b)

Carbon gives 4−0−3=+14-0-3=+1. Chlorine gives 7−8−0=−17-8-0=-1. The starting atoms both had zero formal charge.

(c)

Total charge remains +1−1=0+1-1=0. Initially 4+3+7=144+3+7=14 valence electrons are present. The methyl cation retains six C–H bonding electrons; chloride has eight nonbonding electrons. Thus 6+8=146+8=14. The pair moves from a shared bond into the chlorine nonbonding inventory.