Induction and Polar Covalent Bonds — Question 3

Section 1-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 95–96

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Two polar bonds around oxygen

Use the supplied Pauling electronegativities: H 2.20, C 2.55, N 3.04, O 3.44, F 3.98, Cl 3.16, Li 0.98.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Methanol
  1. Mark the direction of electron-density polarization in C–O and O–H.

  2. Compare their electronegativity differences.

  3. A student replaces each partial-charge label with an integer formal charge. Explain the error.

Question 3 - Solution

Two polar bonds around oxygen

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
Local bond-polarity labels

Qualitative local labels; their magnitudes are not specified or additive numerical charges.

(a)

Both bonds are polarized toward oxygen. Relative to O, the bonded carbon and hydrogen are the positive ends.

(b)

ΔχCO=0.89\Delta\chi_{CO}=0.89, while ΔχOH=1.24\Delta\chi_{OH}=1.24. The O–H difference is larger on the supplied scale.

(c)

Neutral methanol’s ordinary Lewis structure has zero formal charges on all atoms. Unequal physical sharing does not imply a full electron has been transferred. Partial charges describe polarization and depend on the model used to partition electron density; formal charges come from equal sharing of bonding electrons.