Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
A model for attenuation through sigma bonds
For an illustrative induction model, the response magnitude at carbon is , with arbitrary unit and . This is supplied model data, not a universal chemical law.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate .
Find the first carbon where .
Explain what this model captures and what it does not establish about real partial charges.
Question 5 - Solution
A model for attenuation through sigma bonds
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
The response decreases with graph distance from X in this explicitly idealized model.
(a)
, , and arbitrary unit.
(b)
is above 0.10 but is below it, so the first is carbon 4.
(c)
The model captures attenuation of a substituent’s influence with increasing sigma-bond distance. It does not assign actual atomic charges, determine molecular geometry, or establish a universal attenuation factor. Real values depend on structure, medium, and how the response is measured.