Induction and Polar Covalent Bonds — Question 8

Section 1-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 105–106

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Interpreting electrostatic-potential samples

The schematic reports potential values in consistent arbitrary units on two regions of a neutral molecule’s surface. Use U=qVU=qV for a small test charge; treat its perturbation of the molecule as negligible.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

Conceptual potential samples, not a calculated molecular surface.

  1. Which region is favored by a positive test charge?

  2. Compare energies for q=+1q=+1 and for q=−1q=-1.

  3. Explain why the diagram does not imply the molecule has net negative charge.

Question 8 - Solution

Interpreting electrostatic-potential samples

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

A positive test charge has lower energy at A because VAV_A is more negative.

(b)

For q=+1q=+1, UA=−40U_A=-40 and UB=+25U_B=+25. For q=−1q=-1, UA=+40U_A=+40 and UB=−25U_B=-25, so B is favored. All energies use the supplied arbitrary scale.

(c)

Local potential reflects the combined effects of nuclei and electrons at a point in space. A neutral molecule can have positive and negative surface regions. Two sampled potential values are not atomic charges and cannot be summed to obtain net molecular charge.