Atomic Orbitals — Question 4

Section 1-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 117–118

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Diagnosing a Hund-rule error

The displayed diagram is proposed as the ground state of an isolated carbon atom.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the violated ground-state filling rule.

  2. Explain whether the paired electrons themselves violate Pauli exclusion.

  3. Correct the diagram without changing the number of electrons.

Question 4 - Solution

Diagnosing a Hund-rule error

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

It violates Hund’s ground-state rule: degenerate p orbitals are singly occupied with parallel spins before pairing is favored.

(b)

The opposite-spin pair in one box does not violate Pauli exclusion. The issue is the higher-energy arrangement of electrons among available degenerate orbitals, not two identical-spin electrons sharing one orbital.

(c)

Move one p electron to an empty p orbital and use parallel spins for the two singly occupied orbitals. The total remains four valence electrons, with 2s22p22s^2 2p^2 occupancy.