Atomic Orbitals — Question 10

Section 1-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 129–130

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Density at a point versus probability in a shell

For hydrogen 1s, point density is proportional to e−2xe^{-2x}, while radial probability density is proportional to x2e−2xx^2e^{-2x}, where x=r/a0≥0x=r/a_0\ge0. The plotted curves are independently scaled for visibility.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

Curves are qualitative scaled shapes, not normalized to a common vertical unit.

  1. Where is point density largest?

  2. Find the positive-radius maximum of the radial expression by differentiation.

  3. Explain why the radial expression vanishes at the origin despite nonzero point density.

Question 10 - Solution

Density at a point versus probability in a shell

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

e−2xe^{-2x} decreases from its maximum at x=0x=0.

(b)

ddx(x2e−2x)=2x(1−x)e−2x\frac{d}{dx}(x^2e^{-2x})=2x(1-x)e^{-2x}. It increases for 0<x<10<x<1 and decreases for x>1x>1, so the positive-radius maximum is x=1x=1, or r=a0r=a_0.

(c)

A spherical shell carries a volume factor 4πr2dr4\pi r^2\,dr. That factor vanishes at zero radius, so radial probability density is zero there even though point density is largest. This is not a radial node of the 1s wavefunction; it results from the shell-volume factor.