Valence Bond Theory — Question 6

Section 1-7 · Organic Chemistry pages 141–142

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

A geometric model for loss of pi overlap

For an illustrative geometry model, retained pi stabilization is proportional to f(θ)=cos⁡2θf(\theta)=\cos^2\theta, where θ\theta is the twist between adjacent p orbitals. This is not a complete rotational energy calculation.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find ff at 0∘,60∘,90∘0^\circ,60^\circ,90^\circ.

  2. State which orientation loses lateral overlap in this model.

  3. Explain why ordinary free rotation about a double bond is energetically costly.

Question 6 - Solution

A geometric model for loss of pi overlap

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

Angles describe relative p-orbital orientation, not a bond angle at carbon.

(a)

f(0∘)=1f(0^\circ)=1, f(60∘)=1/4f(60^\circ)=1/4, and f(90∘)=0f(90^\circ)=0.

(b)

Perpendicular p orbitals at 90∘90^\circ have no net lateral overlap in this idealized treatment.

(c)

Twisting disrupts the stabilizing pi interaction while the sigma framework can remain connected. Thus rotation about a double bond requires loss of pi stabilization. The model illustrates the geometry but omits rehybridization, electron correlation, and other energy contributions; its values are not measured rotation barriers.