Valence Bond Theory — Question 7

Section 1-7 · Organic Chemistry pages 143–144

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Can a hydrogen 1s orbital make a conventional pi bond?

A student proposes that one C–H bond in methane is a pi bond formed by carbon p and hydrogen 1s overlap.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

The spherical 1s contour illustrates the relevant symmetry, not a methane geometry.

  1. State the symmetry requirement for a pi bond relative to its internuclear axis.

  2. Explain why the hydrogen 1s orbital cannot supply the required lateral partner in this two-center picture.

  3. State the usual classification of all four methane C–H bonds.

Question 7 - Solution

Can a hydrogen 1s orbital make a conventional pi bond?

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

A pi interaction has a nodal plane containing the bond axis and electron density on both sides, arising from appropriate lateral orbital overlap.

(b)

A hydrogen 1s orbital is spherically symmetric and does not have opposite-phase lobes on opposite sides of such a plane. Its overlap with a perpendicular p orbital cancels by symmetry; head-on overlap is instead sigma.

(c)

All four C–H bonds in methane are sigma bonds. The use of carbon p character in a bonding orbital does not automatically make a bond pi.