Radicals — Question 7

Section 11-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 2363–2364

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Reject a neutral four-bond carbon with an extra radical electron

The student labels this a neutral methyl radical.

Deliberately inconsistent neutral assignment
  1. Count H atoms and electrons surrounding carbon.

  2. Compute formal charge if the extra dot is retained.

  3. Repair the drawing to represent a neutral methyl radical.

Question 7 - Solution

Reject a neutral four-bond carbon with an extra radical electron

Correct neutral methyl radical

(a)

It shows four H atoms and nine electrons around carbon: eight bonding plus one unpaired.

(b)

The formal charge would be 4 - 1 - 4 = -1, not zero. This is not an ordinary neutral methyl radical.

(c)

Remove one C–H bond and its H atom, leaving CH3 with three bonds and one dot.