Thermodynamic Considerations for Halogenation Reactions — Question 5

Section 11-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 2419–2420

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Apply a product-like transition-state argument with care

Consider an endothermic H abstraction forming a carbon radical. Use a qualitative Hammond argument.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Is a relatively early or late transition structure expected?

  2. Why can radical stabilization strongly affect this barrier?

  3. Does the profile alone specify an exact transition-state bond length?

Question 5 - Solution

Apply a product-like transition-state argument with care

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

A relatively late, more product-like transition structure is expected.

(b)

Substantial radical character has developed, so factors stabilizing the carbon radical can appreciably stabilize the transition structure.

(c)

No. Hammond reasoning is qualitative; an exact geometry requires additional evidence.