Thermodynamic Considerations for Halogenation Reactions — Question 10

Section 11-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 2429–2430

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Audit the sign convention in a bond-energy solution

The student claims that forming stronger bonds makes Delta H positive.

R-H + Cl2 -> R-Cl + HCl\text{R-H + Cl2 -> R-Cl + HCl}

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Correct the rule.

  2. Explain the physical signs of bond cleavage and formation.

  3. State one limitation of using tabulated average BDEs.

Question 10 - Solution

Audit the sign convention in a bond-energy solution

R-H + Cl2 -> R-Cl + HCl\text{R-H + Cl2 -> R-Cl + HCl}

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Estimate Delta H as bonds broken minus bonds formed.

(b)

Bond cleavage requires energy; bond formation releases energy. Strong newly formed bonds therefore favor a negative estimate.

(c)

Average gas-phase values need not match the exact molecular environment or solution reaction enthalpy. They are estimates, not exact activation energies.