Allylic Bromination — Question 7

Section 11-7 · Organic Chemistry pages 2483–2484

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Explain why resonance-contributor count is not a product-ratio rule

A student predicts a 50:50 bromide mixture merely because two contributors are drawn.

A
B
  1. What is wrong with treating contributors as equal populations?

  2. Name two factors that can influence trapping selectivity.

  3. What conclusion is justified without kinetic data?

Question 7 - Solution

Explain why resonance-contributor count is not a product-ratio rule

A
B

(a)

Contributors are not separate species with independently countable concentrations; they describe one delocalized radical.

(b)

Radical electronic distribution and steric/transition-state effects can influence trapping.

(c)

Both connectivities may be possible; an exact ratio is not established by counting drawings.