Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Decide when a one-step proposal violates the carbon budget
A proposal uses only bromination and base-mediated elimination. No carbon-containing reagent may contribute atoms.
| Only organic starting material |
| Target |
Compare the carbon inventories.
Can any sequence limited to the proposed bond additions and eliminations reach this target?
Give a necessary change to the allowed plan, without inventing a nonexistent one-step reagent.
Question 10 - Solution
Decide when a one-step proposal violates the carbon budget
| Only organic starting material |
| Target |
(a)
But-1-ene has four carbons; pent-1-yne has five.
(b)
No. Bromination and dehydrohalogenation change bonds to H or Br and bond orders, but cannot create the additional carbon atom.
(c)
Allow a carbon-building reaction and a carbon source, or change the starting material to a five-carbon precursor. A reagent name cannot repair an atom deficit.