One-Step Syntheses — Question 10

Section 12-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 2629–2630

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Decide when a one-step proposal violates the carbon budget

A proposal uses only bromination and base-mediated elimination. No carbon-containing reagent may contribute atoms.

Only organic starting material
Target
  1. Compare the carbon inventories.

  2. Can any sequence limited to the proposed bond additions and eliminations reach this target?

  3. Give a necessary change to the allowed plan, without inventing a nonexistent one-step reagent.

Question 10 - Solution

Decide when a one-step proposal violates the carbon budget

Only organic starting material
Target

(a)

But-1-ene has four carbons; pent-1-yne has five.

(b)

No. Bromination and dehydrohalogenation change bonds to H or Br and bond orders, but cannot create the additional carbon atom.

(c)

Allow a carbon-building reaction and a carbon source, or change the starting material to a five-carbon precursor. A reagent name cannot repair an atom deficit.