Reactions that Change the Carbon Skeleton — Question 8

Section 12-3 · Organic Chemistry pages 2665–2666

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Classify rearrangement by graph connectivity rather than molecular formula

Consider a 1,2-methyl shift from the adjacent quaternary carbon. Number the chain left to right C1–C4; call the upper methyl C5 and the lower methyl C6.

Initial carbocation
  1. Identify the broken and formed C–C bonds if C5 migrates.

  2. Locate the positive charge afterward and classify that cation.

  3. Has the carbon skeleton changed even though no carbon was added or removed?

Question 8 - Solution

Classify rearrangement by graph connectivity rather than molecular formula

Rearranged tertiary carbocation

(a)

C3–C5 breaks as C2–C5 forms, with the bonding electron pair migrating.

(b)

The positive charge moves to C3, which is bonded to C2, C4 and C6: a tertiary carbocation.

(c)

Yes. The carbon adjacency changes. All six carbons remain, so carbon count alone misses this skeleton rearrangement.