Preparation of Alcohols via Grignard Reagents — Question 1

Section 13-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 2831–2832

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Identify which end of an organomagnesium bond attacks carbonyl carbon

Use dry ether conditions followed by a separate aqueous workup. The C–Mg bond drawing is a simplified representation of the reagent.

Reagent
Carbonyl partner
  1. Assign the qualitative polarity of C–Mg.

  2. Draw the alcohol and identify the carbon supplied by formaldehyde.

  3. Why is the product primary even though a new C–C bond is formed?

Question 1 - Solution

Identify which end of an organomagnesium bond attacks carbonyl carbon

Propan-1-ol

(a)

Carbon is nucleophilic and relatively delta-negative; Mg is relatively delta-positive.

(b)

Ethyl addition to formaldehyde gives propan-1-ol. The formaldehyde carbon becomes the CH2OH carbon.

(c)

That carbon has only one carbon neighbor and retains two H atoms. New bond formation does not automatically imply a secondary alcohol.