Preparation of Alcohols via Grignard Reagents — Question 5

Section 13-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 2839–2840

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Test the ester-to-tertiary-alcohol rule with a formate ester

Use excess ethylmagnesium bromide and then workup. Apply the same addition–elimination–addition sequence as for other esters.

Ethyl methanoate
  1. Identify the aldehyde intermediate after the first addition and ethoxide loss.

  2. Draw and classify the final carbonyl-derived alcohol.

  3. Explain precisely why the ordinary tertiary-alcohol shortcut fails here.

Question 5 - Solution

Test the ester-to-tertiary-alcohol rule with a formate ester

Secondary alcohol exception

(a)

The first carbonyl intermediate is propanal, because the original carbonyl H is retained.

(b)

A second ethyl adds to propanal, giving pentan-3-ol, a secondary alcohol.

(c)

A formate ester begins with H rather than a carbon substituent at the acyl carbon. Two added ethyl groups plus the retained H give a secondary, not tertiary, alcohol.