Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Audit functional-group compatibility before preparing an organomagnesium reagent
A proposal treats either substrate with Mg in dry ether and expects a persistent carbon nucleophile.
| A |
| B |
Which substrate contains an obvious proton source that destroys the intended reagent?
What is different about the ether oxygen in B?
Does this comparison imply that every functional group lacking OH is compatible?
Question 9 - Solution
Audit functional-group compatibility before preparing an organomagnesium reagent
| A |
| B |
(a)
A contains an OH proton; any carbon–Mg functionality formed is incompatible with that proton source.
(b)
B has an ether and no O–H proton. Ethers can coordinate Mg and are often compatible with Grignard reagents.
(c)
No. Carbonyls, nitriles and other electrophilic groups may react with the nucleophile even when no acidic OH is present.