Introduction to Spectroscopy — Question 10

Section 15-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 3249–3250

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Recognize complementary evidence rather than a unique structural proof

Both candidates have the same molecular formula and an alcohol functional group.

A
B
  1. Would molecular formula alone distinguish them?

  2. Would merely detecting an OH group distinguish them?

  3. What additional kind of evidence could decide between them?

Question 10 - Solution

Recognize complementary evidence rather than a unique structural proof

A
B

(a)

No. Both have formula C3H8O.

(b)

No. Both contain an alcohol OH group.

(c)

Evidence sensitive to connectivity or the full spectral pattern, such as additional spectroscopy or a validated reference comparison, is needed. Shared diagnostic features constrain a structure but need not identify it uniquely.