Hydrogen Deficiency Index: Degrees of Unsaturation — Question 2

Section 15-16 · Organic Chemistry pages 3533–3534

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Explain why oxygen is absent from the usual HDI formula

Both neutral compounds have formula C5H8O2. For ordinary valences, use HDI = (2C + 2 - H)/2 when no N or halogens are present.

A
B
  1. Calculate the HDI for both.

  2. Account for it separately in each drawing.

  3. Why does ignoring oxygen in the formula not mean ignoring carbonyl double bonds?

Question 2 - Solution

Explain why oxygen is absent from the usual HDI formula

A
B

(a)

HDI = (10 + 2 - 8)/2 = 2 for both.

(b)

A has two carbonyl double bonds. B has one carbonyl double bond and one four-membered ring.

(c)

Divalent oxygen does not change the saturated hydrogen-count relation, but each C=O double bond still contributes one degree of unsaturation.