Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Diagnose an impossible neutral hydrocarbon formula
Assume ordinary tetravalent carbon and monovalent hydrogen; no ionic or exotic bonding model.
Calculate the formal HDI result.
Why is the result inconsistent with the stated class?
What must be checked before proposing a structure?
Question 8 - Solution
Diagnose an impossible neutral hydrocarbon formula
(a)
HDI = (8 + 2 - 12)/2 = -1.
(b)
The formula exceeds the maximum hydrogen count C4H10 for a connected ordinary neutral hydrocarbon. A negative ring/pi-bond count is impossible here.
(c)
Check the formula assignment, ion/adduct interpretation and assumptions; do not draw a conventional neutral structure for the impossible formula.