Hydrogen Deficiency Index: Degrees of Unsaturation — Question 10

Section 15-16 · Organic Chemistry pages 3549–3550

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Combine a formula constraint with IR while preserving structural ambiguity

Accurate mass supports neutral C8H8O2. IR supports an aromatic ring and an ester carbonyl; the drawing is one candidate.

Candidate
  1. Calculate total HDI.

  2. Account for all degrees in the candidate methyl benzoate.

  3. Do formula and these broad IR features alone prove this connectivity?

Question 10 - Solution

Combine a formula constraint with IR while preserving structural ambiguity

Candidate

(a)

HDI = (16 + 2 - 8)/2 = 5.

(b)

The benzene ring contributes four and the carbonyl contributes one. The O–CH3 bond adds no unsaturation.

(c)

No. These constraints support the candidate but are not a unique connectivity proof; other ester isomers, such as phenyl acetate, share the formula and broad functional-group features. Additional spectral evidence is needed.