Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Distinguish a fingerprint match from proof of enantiomer identity
Compare pure R and pure S enantiomers using ordinary IR in the same achiral environment.
| Chiral alcohol connectivity |
Should ordinary IR distinguish their absolute configurations?
Does a matching spectrum prove identical enantiomeric composition?
Name the kind of additional discrimination needed.
Question 9 - Solution
Distinguish a fingerprint match from proof of enantiomer identity
| Chiral alcohol connectivity |
(a)
No. Enantiomers have identical ordinary IR spectra under matched achiral conditions.
(b)
No. Matching ordinary IR is compatible with different enantiomeric compositions.
(c)
A chiral measurement or separation, such as chiral chromatography or an appropriate chiroptical method, is needed.