IR Spectroscopy — Question 9

Section 15-2 · Organic Chemistry pages 3267–3268

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Distinguish a fingerprint match from proof of enantiomer identity

Compare pure R and pure S enantiomers using ordinary IR in the same achiral environment.

Chiral alcohol connectivity
  1. Should ordinary IR distinguish their absolute configurations?

  2. Does a matching spectrum prove identical enantiomeric composition?

  3. Name the kind of additional discrimination needed.

Question 9 - Solution

Distinguish a fingerprint match from proof of enantiomer identity

Chiral alcohol connectivity

(a)

No. Enantiomers have identical ordinary IR spectra under matched achiral conditions.

(b)

No. Matching ordinary IR is compatible with different enantiomeric compositions.

(c)

A chiral measurement or separation, such as chiral chromatography or an appropriate chiroptical method, is needed.