Chemical Shift — Question 6

Section 16-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 3641–3642

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Distinguish inductive and aromatic ring-current contributions

Typical illustrative positions are aromatic CH near 7.2 ppm and benzylic CH3 near 2.3 ppm.

Toluene
  1. Which protons occupy the more downfield region?

  2. Does the aromatic ring-current effect require a formal positive charge on those hydrogens?

  3. Why can the benzylic methyl also differ from a remote alkane methyl?

Question 6 - Solution

Distinguish inductive and aromatic ring-current contributions

Toluene

(a)

The aromatic ring hydrogens are more downfield.

(b)

No. An induced magnetic response can alter local shielding without assigning formal positive charges.

(c)

Its proximity to the aromatic pi system and the attached carbon environment alter shielding.