Electrophilic Addition — Question 9

Section 17-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 3887–3888

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Distinguish resonance from competing reaction steps

The two displayed cation drawings are resonance contributors.

Allylic cation contributor A
Allylic cation contributor B
  1. Should they be joined by an equilibrium arrow describing two isolable species?

  2. Why can capture give two constitutional products?

  3. What determines their ratio beyond the existence of two drawings?

Question 9 - Solution

Distinguish resonance from competing reaction steps

Allylic cation contributor A
Allylic cation contributor B

(a)

No. They represent one delocalized intermediate; a resonance arrow is appropriate.

(b)

The intermediate can be trapped at two different positions of its allylic system.

(c)

The relevant capture barriers, conditions and any subsequent equilibration determine the ratio. Counting contributors does not predict equal yields.